13 Hidden Gem Beauty Products Our Editors Always Snag on Their Drugstore Run

“I’ve used this gentle Witch Hazel toner for years! I have rosacea so when I find a product that works with my sensitive skin, I stick to it, in this case for decades.”

– Roberta Correia, Editor-in-Chief, The Everymom

Spend $20, get $3 in ExtraBucks

“I’m obsessed with this moisturizer, mostly because of how thick and hydrating it is—it’s perfect for the colder months or if you have consistently dry skin.”

-Emma Ginsberg, Editorial & Podcast Assistant

Buy 2, get $8 in ExtraBucks

“Not only do these acne patches get rid of any white heads and reduce redness within just a couple of hours of wearing, but they also serve as a fun and unexpected accessory when I wear them out and about for some quick errands. They definitely add that cool-girl feeling to my self care routine—a must buy for sure!”

– McKenna Pringle, Branded Content Editorial Assistant

Buy 2, get $5 in ExtraBucks

“I’ve tried almost every dry shampoo out there, and this is the one I always return to. Not only does it keep my hair non-oily for days on end, but it gives volume like no other. ”

-Bella Gil, Editorial Fashion Assistant

Spend $30, get $10 in ExtraBucks

“I am obsessed with how glowy this makes my skin. It’s lightweight and buildable, and I love that it pulls double-duty as skincare with ingredients like Vitamin C & E.”

– Trisha Sprouse, Branded Content Editor

Buy 2, get $5 in ExtraBucks

“This is one of my all-time beauty obsessions, and for good reason! I collect shades from this collection like Pokémon cards. Each shade is a must-have, effortlessly complementing every skin tone and lip shape. Plus, its long-lasting formula is as reliable as it gets— I’ve dove into messy meals without a second thought and my lip color stays put!”

– Albany Hayes, Sales & Operations Associate

Spend $15, get $5 in ExtraBucks

“They say a smile is your best accessory, so I’ve made it a mission to make mine as sparkling white as possible! When I’m looking for a quick fix before a night out, I’ll always reach for the Hismile Color Correcting Serum to instantly brighten my teeth and conceal yellow stains. The best part? You only need 30 seconds for a quick brush to see a difference!”

– Maddi Goodwin, Account Manager

Buy 1, get $10 in ExtraBucks

“Anytime I’m in a rush for a quick blowout, this is my go-to. It smoothes my thick curls into windswept waves in about 30 minutes.”

-Steph Alleva Cornell, Branded Content Editor

Buy 1, Get $20 in ExtraBucks

“As someone who has very fair skin and a prior melanoma diagnosis, I take my sun safety very seriously. I religiously add Sun Bum’s SPF based lotion as a base layer before makeup even in the winter.”

-Ally Pagar-Wolf, Chief of Sales 

Spend $20, get $5 in ExtraBucks

“This blush gives my cheeks a cute pop of color with just the right amount of shimmer to help my skin look dewy!”

-Kaia Grobe, Video Content Editor

Buy 2, get $5 in ExtraBucks

“I use a prescription Retin-A product which can leave my skin susceptible to dryness. This NO-SOAP cleanser was not only recommended by my aesthetician, but I have been using it for probably 15 years now. Cannot go wrong and does NOT dry your face out!”

– Megan Kemp, Senior Sales Manager

Spend $30, get $10 in ExtraBucks

“I love switching from an intense cream moisturizer to a water-based moisturizer for the summer when I don’t need something as heavy on my skin. This one from Neutrogena is perfect for those hot, sticky days when you want to wear as little on your face as possible: it’s light while still leaving your skin super hydrated.”

– Keely Geist, Senior Social Media Editor

Buy 2, get $5 in ExtraBucks